The result is a portrait that could’ve benefited either from a grander episodic treatment, or a healthy trim, as the film moves so quickly from one talking point to the next almost to the point of inducing whiplash. Still, the insane archival footage of the infernos as they happened makes for an occasionally arresting viewing experience.
“Bring Your Own Brigade” uses a handful of people whose lives were touched by the fires as entry points into the crisis, beginning with Brad Weldon, a man in Paradise that warded the engulfing flames off his home with hoses and buckets, all the while protecting his 90-year-old disabled mother. Weldon’s story is the most emotionally compelling, and the one Walker seems most fascinated by.
Related Influential Awards Bodies Reshape 2023 Best Documentary Feature Race Oscars 2023: Best Documentary Feature Predictions Related 2023 Oscars: ‘Avatar’ Is the One to Beat in Visual Effects Growing Number of Contenders Makes 2023 Best International Feature Race Less Predictable
It’s interesting to see the friction start to emerge between the filmmaker and some of her subjects, as fellow Paradise residents disavow climate change as a contributing factor in their fires. But Walker and Weldon (along with his mother, blissed out on weed cookies) seem to have the best rapport. “We’re still here. We didn’t burn down,” Weldon says.
Others were not so lucky. “Bring Your Own Brigade” features testimonies from dozens of people who lost loved ones or personal effects in the fires in the ensuing scramble as evacuation warnings, Walker points out, simply didn’t happen. The blazes that tore apart Malibu with the Woolsey Fire that ignited in November 2018, Malibu Fire Captain Rick Mullen says, were “like peering into Dante’s inferno.” Indeed, Walker ramps up the hellish atmosphere, from tableaux of charred animals to harrowing phone calls to first responders of people screaming for their lives.
Courtesy of Sundance Institute | photo by Lucy Walker
There’s also footage of Southern California that went viral at the time of the usual 405 and PCH traffic slow-crawling beneath arches of flames. The horrors are tipped into overkill with the inclusion of music by the likes of Sigur Ros and Max Richter, which certainly contributes dramatic effect, but feels unnecessarily overlaid onto what is inherently excruciating to watch. It feels like “I’m on an acid trip that might not end,” says one survivor.
“Bring Your Own Brigade” bounces around from the various phenomena that paved the way for the fires to happen in California in the first place, from the Gold Rush of the 1800s to deforestation to the lack of funding for fire departments. It’s a dizzying, unwieldy experience that could send you for your notepad. The film also dwells far too long on an epilogue that tries to check in on all of the film’s subjects, with saccharine music providing the finish to stretches of memoriam. When Walker’s film is most thrilling is in moments like a Northern California town council meeting where, with the filmmaker herself in attendance, committee members vote en masse against measures that could shore up the state’s fire-proofing infrastructure. This film is shaggy in its structure, and overall visually flat without a bevy of filmmaker-y flourishes, and that’s surely intentional to starkly portray the tragic human face of the fires. Lacking the concision to bring home its argument, “Bring Your Own Brigade” isn’t going to flip the script on what is a dyed-in-the-wool systemic mess. But it does provide a necessary reflection on a dark period in California history that, to the surprise of no one, just repeated itself in 2020.
Grade: C+
“Bring Your Own Brigade” debuted at the 2021 Sundance Film Festival in the Premieres section. It is currently seeking U.S. distribution. Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.
